| | | Edinboro wins the toss and defers. Mercyhurst will receive. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc30 | EDIN ball on EDIN30. |
| | | Nick Daley kickoff 55 yards to the MC15, out-of-bounds, MC ball on MC40. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc40 | Gerald Anderson rush for 13 yards to the EDIN47, 1ST DOWN MC (Kenny Pettis). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Edin47 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete to Jeff Groene. |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Edin47 | Travis Rearick rush for 14 yards to the EDIN33, 1ST DOWN MC (James Thomas). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Edin33 | Gerald Anderson rush for 6 yards to the EDIN27 (Dan Skelton). |
| Mc | 2-4 | at Edin27 | Trevor Kennedy pass complete to Paris Bruner for 12 yards to the EDIN15, 1ST DOWN MC (James Jackson). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Edin15 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete. |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Edin15 | Gerald Anderson rush for 3 yards to the EDIN12 (Ryan Skelton). |
| Mc | 3-7 | at Edin12 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Gerald Anderson for 8 yards to the EDIN4, 1ST DOWN MC (Ryan Skelton;Greg Sondag). |
| Mc | 1-G | at Edin04 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete to Jeff Groene. |
| Mc | 2-G | at Edin04 | Gerald Anderson rush for loss of 5 yards to the EDIN9 (Keir Jeter;Ryan Skelton). |
| Mc | 3-G | at Edin09 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Ryan Bartizal for 9 yards to the EDIN0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:28. |
| | | S Wakefield kick attempt good. |
| | | Mercyhurst College 7, Edinboro 0 |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 60 yards, TOP 04:32 |
| | | S Wakefield kickoff 50 yards to the EDIN20, Gary Nolen return -4 yards to the EDIN16 (L.J. Stevens). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin16 | EDINBORO drive start at 10:28. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin16 | Drew Herrell rush for 6 yards to the EDIN22 (Bryant Kimball;Alex Trouten). |
| Edin | 2-4 | at Edin22 | Drew Herrell rush for no gain to the EDIN22 (Bryan Boyce). |
| Edin | 3-4 | at Edin22 | Cody Harris sacked for loss of 5 yards to the EDIN17 (Fred Hale;Kevin Williams). |
| Edin | 4-9 | at Edin17 | Ryan Genco punt 56 yards to the MC27, Trevor Kennedy return 10 yards to the MC37, fumble forced by Ryan Skelton, fumble by Trevor Kennedy recovered by EDIN Ryan Skelton at MC37. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 02:09 |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc37 | EDINBORO drive start at 08:19. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc37 | Drew Herrell rush for 3 yards to the MC34 (Dan Kruper). |
| Edin | 2-7 | at Mc34 | Drew Herrell rush for 3 yards to the MC31 (Alex Trouten;Dan Kruper). |
| Edin | 3-4 | at Mc31 | Drew Herrell rush for 1 yard to the MC30 (Bryan Boyce;Fred Hale). |
| Edin | 4-3 | at Mc30 | Cody Harris sacked for loss of 8 yards to the MC38 (Ryan Taylor;Fred Hale). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:46 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc38 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 06:33. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc38 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Trevor Kennedy for 12 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN MC (Dan Skelton). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc50 | Gerald Anderson rush for 3 yards to the EDIN47 (Greg Sondag;Mike Perillo). |
| Mc | 2-7 | at Edin47 | Gerald Anderson rush for no gain to the EDIN47 (Dan Skelton), PENALTY MC holding 10 yards to the MC43, NO PLAY. |
| Mc | 2-17 | at Mc43 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete to Ryan Bartizal (Dan Skelton). |
| Mc | 3-17 | at Mc43 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete. |
| Mc | 4-17 | at Mc43 | Chad Tibbitts punt 25 yards to the EDIN32, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:30 |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin32 | EDINBORO drive start at 05:03. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin32 | PENALTY MC offside 5 yards to the EDIN37. |
| Edin | 1-5 | at Edin37 | Cody Harris pass complete to Gary Nolen for 8 yards to the EDIN45, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Ryan Taylor). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin45 | Cody Harris rush for 3 yards to the EDIN48 (Bryan Boyce;Dan Kruper), PENALTY MC face mask 15 yards to the MC37, 1ST DOWN EDIN. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc37 | 1st and 10. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc37 | Cody Harris pass complete to Gary Nolen for 22 yards to the MC15, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Bryant Kimball). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc15 | Drew Herrell rush for 6 yards to the MC9 (Bryan Boyce). |
| Edin | 2-4 | at Mc09 | PENALTY EDIN false start 5 yards to the MC14. |
| Edin | 2-9 | at Mc14 | Cody Harris rush for 10 yards to the MC4, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Kevin Williams). |
| Edin | 1-G | at Mc04 | David Bostic rush for loss of 2 yards to the MC6 (Tim Herbener;Kevin Williams). |
| Edin | 2-G | at Mc06 | Cody Harris pass complete to Josh Brown for 6 yards to the MC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:42. |
| | | Alex Romanias kick attempt good. |
| | | Mercyhurst College 7, Edinboro 7 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 68 yards, TOP 03:21 |
| | | Nick Daley kickoff 70 yards to the MC0, Andrew Bailey return 21 yards to the MC21 (Ryan Skelton). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc21 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 01:42. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc21 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Trevor Kennedy for 6 yards to the MC27 (Kenny Pettis;Ben Swank). |
| Mc | 2-4 | at Mc27 | Trevor Kennedy rush for loss of 2 yards to the MC25 (Jelani Murray;Dan Skelton). |
| Mc | 3-6 | at Mc25 | Travis Rearick pass complete to R.J. Miller for 6 yards to the MC31 (Ben Swank), PENALTY MC holding 10 yards to the MC15, NO PLAY. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, minus 6 yards, TOP 01:58 |
| | | Mercyhurst College 7, Edinboro 7 |
| Mc | 3-16 | at Mc15 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mc | 3-16 | at Mc15 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete to Matt Mohr. |
| Mc | 4-16 | at Mc15 | Chad Tibbitts punt 43 yards to the EDIN42, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 6 yards, TOP 01:58 |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin42 | EDINBORO drive start at 14:44. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin42 | Drew Herrell rush for 4 yards to the EDIN46 (Bryan Boyce). |
| Edin | 2-6 | at Edin46 | Drew Herrell rush for no gain to the EDIN46 (Alex Trouten). |
| Edin | 3-6 | at Edin46 | Cody Harris pass complete to David Bostic for 12 yards to the MC42, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Ryan Taylor). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc42 | Drew Herrell rush for 9 yards to the MC33 (Ryan Taylor;Bryant Kimball). |
| Edin | 2-1 | at Mc33 | Drew Herrell rush for 2 yards to the MC31, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Alex Trouten). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc31 | Drew Herrell rush for 5 yards to the MC26 (Bryan Boyce;Andrew Bukta). |
| Edin | 2-5 | at Mc26 | Drew Herrell rush for 4 yards to the MC22 (Bryant Kimball;Alex Trouten). |
| Edin | 3-1 | at Mc22 | Drew Herrell rush for 4 yards to the MC18, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Ryan Taylor). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc18 | Drew Herrell rush for 4 yards to the MC14 (Bryant Kimball;Ian Wild). |
| Edin | 2-6 | at Mc14 | Drew Herrell rush for loss of 1 yard to the MC15 (Dan Kruper;Tim Herbener). |
| Edin | 3-7 | at Mc15 | Cody Harris pass complete to Gary Nolen for 2 yards to the MC13 (Brandon Harper). |
| Edin | 4-5 | at Mc13 | Alex Romanias field goal attempt from 30 MISSED - wide right, spot at MC20, clock 08:53. |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 45 yards, TOP 05:51 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc20 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 08:53. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc20 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Jeff Groene for 13 yards to the MC33, 1ST DOWN MC (Jake Wickline). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc33 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Trevor Kennedy for 3 yards to the MC36 (Kenny Pettis). |
| Mc | 2-7 | at Mc36 | Gerald Anderson rush for 1 yard to the MC37 (Zack Spearing). |
| Mc | 3-6 | at Mc37 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete. |
| Mc | 4-6 | at Mc37 | Chad Tibbitts punt 36 yards to the EDIN27, Ben Swank return 7 yards to the EDIN34 (Bryan Boyce;L.J. Stevens). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 17 yards, TOP 02:05 |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin34 | EDINBORO drive start at 06:48. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin34 | Cody Harris pass complete to Gary Nolen for 14 yards to the EDIN48, 1ST DOWN EDIN, out-of-bounds (Brandon Harper). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin48 | Drew Herrell rush for 7 yards to the MC45 (Ryan Taylor;Brad Weisenseel). |
| Edin | 2-3 | at Mc45 | Cody Harris pass incomplete to Gary Nolen. |
| Edin | 3-3 | at Mc45 | Drew Herrell rush for 4 yards to the MC41, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Dan Kruper). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc41 | PENALTY EDIN false start 5 yards to the MC46. |
| Edin | 1-15 | at Mc46 | Cody Harris pass incomplete. |
| Edin | 2-15 | at Mc46 | Cody Harris rush for 1 yard to the MC45. |
| Edin | 3-14 | at Mc45 | Cody Harris pass incomplete to D'mar Jeter (Brandon Harper). |
| Edin | 4-14 | at Mc45 | Ryan Genco punt 33 yards to the MC12, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 21 yards, TOP 02:52 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc12 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 03:56. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc12 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete. |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Mc12 | Gerald Anderson rush for 8 yards to the MC20 (Dan Skelton). |
| Mc | 3-2 | at Mc20 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete to Jeff Groene (Ryan Skelton). |
| Mc | 4-2 | at Mc20 | Chad Tibbitts punt 38 yards to the EDIN42, Ben Swank return 4 yards to the EDIN46 (Ian Wild). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:08 |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin46 | EDINBORO drive start at 02:48. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin46 | Cody Harris rush for 5 yards to the MC49 (Tim Herbener). |
| Edin | 2-5 | at Mc49 | Cody Harris rush for 7 yards to the MC42, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Kevin Williams;Ryan Taylor). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc42 | Cody Harris pass complete to Drew Herrell for 2 yards to the MC40 (Tim Herbener;Ian Wild). |
| Edin | 2-8 | at Mc40 | Cody Harris pass incomplete to D'mar Jeter (J McCormick). |
| Edin | 3-8 | at Mc40 | PENALTY EDIN delay of game 5 yards to the MC45. |
| Edin | 3-13 | at Mc45 | Cody Harris pass complete to Gary Nolen for 2 yards to the MC43 (Dan Kruper). |
| Edin | 4-11 | at Mc43 | J.D. Rodgers punt 41 yards to the MC2, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 11 yards, TOP 02:07 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc02 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 00:41. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc02 | Gerald Anderson rush for 1 yard to the MC3 (Zack Spearing). |
| Mc | 2-9 | at Mc03 | Timeout Edinboro, clock 00:35. |
| Mc | 2-9 | at Mc03 | Gerald Anderson rush for 2 yards to the MC5 (Jordan Krentz;Zack Spearing). |
| Mc | 3-7 | at Mc05 | Timeout Edinboro, clock 00:28. |
| Mc | 3-7 | at Mc05 | Gerald Anderson rush for 4 yards to the MC9 (Kenny Pettis). |
| Mc | 4-3 | at Mc09 | Timeout Edinboro, clock 00:19. |
| Mc | 4-3 | at Mc09 | Chad Tibbitts punt 35 yards to the MC44, Ben Swank return 0 yards to the MC44 (L.J. Stevens). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 00:31 |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc44 | EDINBORO drive start at 00:10. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc44 | Cody Harris pass incomplete to Gary Nolen. |
| Edin | 2-10 | at Mc44 | Cody Harris sacked for loss of 7 yards to the EDIN49 (Dan Kruper;Bryan Boyce). |
| Edin | 3-17 | at Edin49 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, minus 7 yards, TOP 00:10 |
| | | Mercyhurst College 7, Edinboro 7 |
| Edin | 3-17 | at Edin49 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, MC ball on MC30. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, minus 7 yards, TOP 00:10 |
| | | S Wakefield kickoff 62 yards to the EDIN8, Gary Nolen return 18 yards to the EDIN26 (Bryan Boyce), PENALTY EDIN illegal block 10 yards to the EDIN16, 1st and 10, EDIN ball on EDIN16. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin16 | EDINBORO drive start at 15:00. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin16 | PENALTY EDIN holding 5 yards to the EDIN11. |
| Edin | 1-15 | at Edin11 | Cody Harris pass complete to Shawn Walker for 21 yards to the EDIN32, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Bryant Kimball). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin32 | Drew Herrell rush for loss of 3 yards to the EDIN29 (Ryan Taylor). |
| Edin | 2-13 | at Edin29 | Cody Harris pass complete to D'mar Jeter for 35 yards to the MC36, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Bryant Kimball). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc36 | Drew Herrell rush for 6 yards to the MC30 (Ian Wild). |
| Edin | 2-4 | at Mc30 | Cody Harris pass complete to Shawn Walker for 9 yards to the MC21, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Ryan Taylor). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc21 | Drew Herrell rush for no gain to the MC21 (Ryan Taylor), PENALTY EDIN holding 10 yards to the MC31, NO PLAY. |
| Edin | 1-20 | at Mc31 | Cody Harris rush for 10 yards to the MC21 (Ryan Taylor). |
| Edin | 2-10 | at Mc21 | Cody Harris rush for 1 yard to the MC20 (Kevin Williams;Alex Trouten), PENALTY MC personal foul 10 yards to the MC10, 1ST DOWN EDIN. |
| Edin | 1-G | at Mc10 | 1st and 10. |
| Edin | 1-G | at Mc10 | Drew Herrell rush for 3 yards to the MC7 (Ian Wild). |
| Edin | 2-G | at Mc07 | Drew Herrell rush for 7 yards to the MC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:37. |
| | | Alex Romanias kick attempt good. |
| | | Edinboro 14, Mercyhurst College 7 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 84 yards, TOP 04:23 |
| | | Nick Daley kickoff 68 yards to the MC2, Andrew Bailey return 21 yards to the MC23 (Kyle Maio;Jake Wickline). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc23 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 10:37. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc23 | Gerald Anderson rush for 10 yards to the MC33, 1ST DOWN MC (Ryan Skelton). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc33 | Gerald Anderson rush for 9 yards to the MC42 (Dan Skelton). |
| Mc | 2-1 | at Mc42 | Gerald Anderson rush for 3 yards to the MC45, 1ST DOWN MC (Matt Caternolo;Jesse Wattle). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc45 | Gerald Anderson rush for 5 yards to the 50 yardline (Ben Swank;Dan Skelton). |
| Mc | 2-5 | at Mc50 | Gerald Anderson rush for 3 yards to the EDIN47 (Jake Wickline). |
| Mc | 3-2 | at Edin47 | Gerald Anderson rush for 5 yards to the EDIN42, fumble forced by Keir Jeter, fumble by Gerald Anderson recovered by EDIN Ben Swank at EDIN42. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 35 yards, TOP 03:05 |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin42 | EDINBORO drive start at 07:32. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin42 | Cody Harris pass complete to David Bostic for 5 yards to the EDIN47 (Tim Herbener;Dustin Galich). |
| Edin | 2-5 | at Edin47 | Drew Herrell rush for 8 yards to the MC45, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Ian Wild;Fred Hale). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc45 | Cody Harris pass incomplete to Shawn Walker. |
| Edin | 2-10 | at Mc45 | Cody Harris pass complete to Gary Nolen for loss of 1 yard to the MC46 (Bryan Boyce). |
| Edin | 3-11 | at Mc46 | Cody Harris pass incomplete to Gary Nolen (Mike Brown), PENALTY EDIN illegal block declined. |
| Edin | 4-11 | at Mc46 | Ryan Genco punt 46 yards to the MC0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 12 yards, TOP 01:59 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc20 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 05:33. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc20 | Gerald Anderson rush for 3 yards to the MC23 (Greg Sondag;Jake Wickline). |
| Mc | 2-7 | at Mc23 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Terrance Coon for 8 yards to the MC31, 1ST DOWN MC, out-of-bounds. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc31 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Jeff Groene for 7 yards to the MC38 (Greg Sondag;Jelani Murray). |
| Mc | 2-3 | at Mc38 | Gerald Anderson rush for 4 yards to the MC42, 1ST DOWN MC (Jordan Krentz). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc42 | Andrew Bailey rush for 5 yards to the MC47 (Dan Skelton). |
| Mc | 2-5 | at Mc47 | Andrew Bailey rush for 3 yards to the 50 yardline (Bobby Kmetz;Ryan Skelton). |
| Mc | 3-2 | at Mc50 | Andrew Bailey rush for 1 yard to the EDIN49 (Ben Swank;Bobby Kmetz). |
| Mc | 4-1 | at Edin49 | Andrew Bailey rush for 4 yards to the EDIN45, 1ST DOWN MC (Ben Swank;Dan Skelton). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Edin45 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Jeff Groene for 6 yards to the EDIN39 (Kenny Pettis). |
| Mc | 2-4 | at Edin39 | Gerald Anderson rush for 1 yard to the EDIN38 (Zack Spearing;Kenny Pettis). |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 42 yards, TOP 07:10 |
| | | Edinboro 14, Mercyhurst College 7 |
| Mc | 3-3 | at Edin38 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mc | 3-3 | at Edin38 | Gerald Anderson rush for 3 yards to the EDIN35, 1ST DOWN MC (Zack Spearing;Keir Jeter). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Edin35 | Gerald Anderson rush for 1 yard to the EDIN34 (Jake Wickline). |
| Mc | 2-9 | at Edin34 | Travis Rearick pass intercepted by Ben Swank at the EDIN26, Ben Swank return 60 yards to the MC14 (Kevin Poropat), PENALTY EDIN unsportsmanlike conduct 15 yards to the MC29, 1st and 10, EDIN ball on MC29. |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 46 yards, TOP 07:10 |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc29 | EDINBORO drive start at 13:23. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc29 | Cody Harris sacked for loss of 5 yards to the MC34 (Tim Herbener;Dan Kruper). |
| Edin | 2-15 | at Mc34 | Drew Herrell rush for 3 yards to the MC31 (Bryan Boyce;Tim Herbener). |
| Edin | 3-12 | at Mc31 | Cody Harris rush for 2 yards to the MC29 (Alex Trouten;Andrew Bukta). |
| Edin | 4-10 | at Mc29 | J.D. Rodgers punt 10 yards to the MC19, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 02:02 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc19 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 11:21. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc19 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Trevor Kennedy for 6 yards to the MC25 (Ryan Skelton). |
| Mc | 2-4 | at Mc25 | Gerald Anderson rush for 3 yards to the MC28 (Ryan Skelton). |
| Mc | 3-1 | at Mc28 | Gerald Anderson rush for 1 yard to the MC29 (Matt Caternolo;Dan Skelton), PENALTY MC holding 10 yards to the MC18, NO PLAY. |
| Mc | 3-11 | at Mc18 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Trevor Kennedy for 6 yards to the MC24 (Mike Perillo;Zack Spearing). |
| Mc | 4-5 | at Mc24 | Chad Tibbitts punt 38 yards to the EDIN38, fair catch by Ben Swank. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 02:18 |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin38 | EDINBORO drive start at 09:03. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin38 | Cody Harris pass complete to D. Sidorick for 4 yards to the EDIN42 (Bryant Kimball). |
| Edin | 2-6 | at Edin42 | Drew Herrell rush for 3 yards to the EDIN45 (Bryan Boyce;Ian Wild). |
| Edin | 3-3 | at Edin45 | Cody Harris rush for 5 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Ian Wild). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin50 | Drew Herrell rush for no gain to the 50 yardline (Bryan Boyce). |
| Edin | 2-10 | at Edin50 | Cody Harris pass complete to Gary Nolen for 2 yards to the MC48 (Ryan Taylor). |
| Edin | 3-8 | at Mc48 | Cody Harris pass incomplete. |
| Edin | 4-8 | at Mc48 | Ryan Genco punt 46 yards to the MC2, Trevor Kennedy return 40 yards to the MC42 (Brandon Marlow). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 14 yards, TOP 03:40 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc42 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 05:23. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc42 | Gerald Anderson rush for 2 yards to the MC44 (Dan Skelton;Greg Sondag). |
| Mc | 2-8 | at Mc44 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete to Terrance Coon. |
| Mc | 3-8 | at Mc44 | Travis Rearick sacked for loss of 14 yards to the MC30 (James Thomas). |
| Mc | 4-22 | at Mc30 | Chad Tibbitts punt 35 yards to the EDIN35, Ben Swank return 3 yards to the EDIN38, PENALTY EDIN illegal block 10 yards to the EDIN28, 1st and 10, EDIN ball on EDIN28. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 12 yards, TOP 01:32 |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin28 | EDINBORO drive start at 03:51. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin28 | David Bostic rush for 3 yards to the EDIN31, fumble forced by Dan Kruper, fumble by David Bostic recovered by MC Bryant Kimball at EDIN31. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:48 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Edin31 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 03:03. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Edin31 | Gerald Anderson rush for loss of 2 yards to the EDIN33 (Kenny Pettis). |
| Mc | 2-12 | at Edin33 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete to Trevor Kennedy (James Jackson). |
| Mc | 3-12 | at Edin33 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Gerald Anderson for 2 yards to the EDIN31 (Matt Caternolo;Zack Spearing). |
| Mc | 4-10 | at Edin31 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Trevor Kennedy for 16 yards to the EDIN15, 1ST DOWN MC (Ryan Skelton). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Edin15 | Gerald Anderson rush for 6 yards to the EDIN9 (Mike Perillo). |
| Mc | 2-4 | at Edin09 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete to R.J. Miller. |
| Mc | 3-4 | at Edin09 | Gerald Anderson rush for 9 yards to the EDIN0, 1ST DOWN MC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:59. |
| | | S Wakefield kick attempt good. |
| | | Mercyhurst College 14, Edinboro 14 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 31 yards, TOP 02:04 |
| | | S Wakefield kickoff 70 yards to the EDIN0, Gary Nolen return 23 yards to the EDIN23 (Tim Herbener). |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin23 | EDINBORO drive start at 00:59. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin23 | Cody Harris rush for 1 yard to the EDIN24, PENALTY EDIN illegal forward pass 5 yards to the EDIN19. |
| Edin | 1-14 | at Edin19 | 2nd and 14. |
| Edin | 2-14 | at Edin19 | Drew Herrell rush for 1 yard to the EDIN20 (Kevin Williams). |
| Edin | 3-13 | at Edin20 | Drew Herrell rush for 6 yards to the EDIN26 (Bryant Kimball;Bryan Boyce). |
| Edin | 4-7 | at Edin26 | Timeout Mercyhurst College, clock 00:33. |
| Edin | 4-7 | at Edin26 | Ryan Genco punt 24 yards to the 50 yardline, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:33 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc50 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 00:26. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc50 | Travis Rearick pass incomplete. |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Mc50 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Trevor Kennedy for 20 yards to the EDIN30, 1ST DOWN MC (Mike Perillo;Zack Spearing). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Edin30 | TEAM pass incomplete. |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Edin30 | S Wakefield field goal attempt from 47 MISSED - wide left, spot at EDIN30, clock 00:03. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 20 yards, TOP 00:23 |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin30 | EDINBORO drive start at 00:03. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Edin30 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the EDIN29. |
| Edin | 2-11 | at Edin29 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:03 |
| | | Mercyhurst College 14, Edinboro 14 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 25 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Mercyhurst College 22, Edinboro 21 |
| Edin | 2-11 | at Edin29 | Start of OT quarter, clock 15:00. |
| | | Mercyhurst won toss and chose defense, going to the South end of field |
| Edin | 2-11 | at Edin29 | EDIN ball on MC25. |
| Edin | 2-11 | at Mc25 | 1st and 10. |
| Edin | 1-10 | at Mc25 | Drew Herrell rush for 1 yard to the MC24 (Alex Trouten). |
| Edin | 2-9 | at Mc24 | Cody Harris pass complete to Josh Brown for 19 yards to the MC5, 1ST DOWN EDIN (Brandon Harper). |
| Edin | 1-G | at Mc05 | Cody Harris rush for 4 yards to the MC1 (Alex Trouten). |
| Edin | 2-G | at Mc01 | Cody Harris rush for 1 yard to the MC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 15:00. |
| | | Alex Romanias kick attempt good. |
| | | Edinboro 21, Mercyhurst College 14 |
| Edin | 1-G | at Edin30 | Change of possession, MC ball on EDIN25, 1st and 10. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:03 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Edin25 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 15:00. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Edin25 | Gerald Anderson rush for 5 yards to the EDIN20 (Dan Skelton;Keir Jeter). |
| Mc | 2-5 | at Edin20 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Trevor Kennedy for 11 yards to the EDIN9, 1ST DOWN MC (Zack Spearing). |
| Mc | 1-G | at Edin09 | Gerald Anderson rush for loss of 2 yards to the EDIN11 (Ryan Skelton). |
| Mc | 2-G | at Edin11 | Travis Rearick pass complete to Terrance Coon for 11 yards to the EDIN0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 15:00. |
| Mc | 1-G | at Edin03 | PENALTY EDIN offside 2 yards to the EDIN1. |
| Mc | 1-G | at Edin01 | Timeout Mercyhurst College, clock 15:00. |
| Mc | 1-G | at Edin01 | Timeout Edinboro, clock 15:00. |
| | | Travis Rearick pass attempt to Trevor Kennedy good. |
| | | Mercyhurst College 22, Edinboro 21 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 25 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Mercyhurst College 22, Edinboro 21 |